Friday, November 28, 2008

How much marketing does it take to get to the BCS?

Dan Wetzel of Yahoo Sports has a wonderful piece on the politics of lobbying for a spot in the BCS championship game.


His article details how LSU, with two losses, managed to lobby its way into the BCS a year ago on a marketing effort based on an observation from Kathy Miles, the wife of coach Les Miles. Her observation was simple and ultimately proved a successful lobbying argument.  LSU hadn't lost in regulation.  Two losses didn't really count, because neither was in regulation.  LSU's athletic department and politicking team were successful in selling that message to human poll voters, enough to garner a spot in the championship game.

No one here is arguing whether LSU deserved a shot a national title last year.  They were an outstanding team and would have had an envious seed in a playoff tournament were one in place.  The point here is to once again demonstrate a major fallacy in a primary argument for the BCS.

BCS supporters contend that with the BCS, the regular season functions as a de facto playoff system, a weekly whittling of champion hopefuls down to two.  If the BCS were successful at making the regular season a weekly playoff, then there would be no need for any post-season lobbying to participate in the championship game.  The "playoff" would produce two clear choices.

Of course that doesn't happen, and the reason is simple:  the BCS is not successful at making the regular season a weekly playoff.


Thursday, November 20, 2008

Always a Good Time

Three congressmen have revived a bill designed to end the BCS:

http://www.sportsline.com/collegefootball/story/11121011/rss

Now, some may say that in the midst of an economic meltdown, the potential of hundreds of thousands of jobs to be lost in the American auto industry and elsewhere (if not millions), state governments in financial turmoil, war on two fronts (still), an increasingly fragile infrastructure, a health-care system that works as long as you are rich or don't get sick, a transfer of executive power, a ten-trillion-dollar national debt (think: your children's children's children will still be paying off that albatross), a voracious and insatiable dependence on foreign oil, a daily fear of an inevitable terrorist attack (whether a well-founded fear or not, does it really matter?)... some may say that in such a climate, our elected officials have better things to do than worry about some post-season system for playing football games. But of course, those people are wrong, for one simple reason.

It is always a good time to dismantle, annihilate, extinguish, obliterate, exterminate, or otherwise dance-on-the-grave of this monstrosity soon-to-be-formerly-known as the BCS.

All the best to congressmen Abercrombie, Simpson, and Matheson and their bipartisan effort to end this post-season monopolistic system. I have no doubt that if a special election were held today, with a single ballot measure to replace the BCS with a proper playoff system, Americans would vote for it in the high 90-percent range. Is there any issue with such lopsided support in America today?

Sure there are bigger problems, but this one is a no-brainer.

Monday, November 3, 2008

Obama wants a playoff!

Maybe the good senator could have some influence over the NCAA and college presidents? If he's elected President tomorrow, he'll have plenty more to worry about than how College Football div. 1-A selects a national champion. Still, when ESPN's Chris Berman asked if he could change just one thing about sport, Sen. Obama said it was time to have a college football playoff.

And if you didn't have enough reasons to vote for him, add BCS-ending to the list. Or at least a desire to end it.

Obama, McCain on what to change in sports (A.P.)

For his part, Sen. McCain had a good answer too (preventing the spread and use of performance-enhancing drugs).


Thursday, June 19, 2008

Swinging the Balance of Power

Responding to a question on whether or not the recent announcement that two BCS commissioners (Mike Tranghese, Tom Hansen) and Notre Dame's AD Kevin White are leaving and/or retiring will better the chances for a college football playoff, Stewart Mandel of SI says probably not. Mandel suggests that the deck is so far stacked among the remaining commissioners against a playoff that even if the incoming replacements were in favor of a playoff, it would like not "swing the balance of power."

I wonder... if Tranghese in particular was a driving force - a leadership force - for keeping the BCS, removing that influence may have more of an effect than we realize. Mandel may be right when he writes that commissioners "act primarily as mouthpieces for their member schools' presidents and chancellors". That said, it seems there is growing support among institutions, if not the overwheming support that exists among fans, to see a post-season championship playoff.

I imagine that the timing to retire for Tranghese and Hansen was well designed to ensure one last extension of the current BCS system.

Friday, May 9, 2008

A Healthy Regular Season

As a college football fan who would like to have a clear division 1-A national champion crowned, it heartens me to read articles like that recently posted by Matt Zemek of CollegeFootballNews.com. In the post, Mr. Zemek acknowledges the arrogance of the BCS commissioners who recently shot down a plus-one playoff format and encourages a boycott of bowl game attendance for the upcoming season.

That is a very strong thing to ask for, particularly from one who is so knowledgeable, and such a fan, of the sport. But it made me consider something. Those who protect the BCS system as it currently exists are constantly touting how precious is the regular season. Zemek makes it very clear that he is not calling for a boycott of regular season games, just the bowl game.

So treat this as a thought experiment: imagine a 2008 season with record attendances during the regular season, but every one of the 34 bowl games is played in an empty venue due to a fan boycott. Record revenues from regular-season attendance are seen across the country, but the bowls instantly become a financial fiasco. Following such a spectacle, do BCS commissioners continue to trumpet the regular season as they do now?

Even if you're a fan of the current BCS system, if you answered "no" to the above question, you have to acknowledge that the health of the regular season isn't the driving factor to the commissioners' decision to stonewall a playoff.

Wednesday, May 7, 2008

The Ten Percent Experience

It continues to amaze me how there are people that consider a playoff in College Football div. 1-A would somehow diminish the value of the regular season. Sports Illustrated's Stewart Mandel insists that this is the real reason behind the recent decision of BCS commissioners to torpedo a plus-one post-season format.

I've written in prior posts how this is a red herring - that limiting championship eligibility to only two teams (and for the most part decided by vote at that) actually devalues the regular seasons for many teams, year after year. I described a "Championship Eligibility ratio" - the ratio of the number of teams eligible for their league's national championship to the total number of teams in the league - as a useful metric for considering the "value" of a given league's regular season. Have a ratio too high, like in the NBA, and the regular season for its teams is watered down. But have a ratio too low, like in the BCS, and several deserving teams year after year never get a shot, equally diminishing the value of their regular seasons.

Here's another metric. In college football, teams only play 12 regular season games. That's a total of 12 opponents. That means that each team in division 1-A football plays only about ten percent of the total divisional competition during the regular season. Is that really a large enough representation to definitively select, through arbitrary selection, only two teams for championship eligibility? Does anyone really think that? 10%?

Put another way: every division 1-A college football team during every regular season barely scratches the surface of the available competition pool. At seasons' end, there are 11 conference champions, and several other teams with cases to be made that their 10% experience matches up with anyone else's.

The point to a playoff is to recognize that the 10% experience is inherently limited. Those with the best 10% experiences become representatives in a playoff. A fully-played tournament is a time-efficient means for translating individual 10% experiences into a full 100% champion, without having to play all 119 teams against eachother. The best representatives for the regular season play instead.

Catch that? The best representatives for the regular season get to play for the national championship. If a team performs poorly for the regular season, they don't get to the playoff. It's that simple. The regular season matters, with or without a playoff post-season. It's a red herring. The only way it isn't a red herring is if too many teams are invited to the post-season.

So don't have a 64-team brawl! An 8-team tournament playoff represents only about seven percent of all the division's teams. Isn't that elite enough?

Sunday, May 4, 2008

More bowls?

The NCAA has approved two new bowl games, taking the number of bowls to 34 for the 2008 season.

I wonder at what point over-saturation hit with bowls... was it at 16? 20? I'm sure it was well before the 32 we had in 2007. We now have the St. Petersburg bowl and the Congressional bowl.

But I guess it isn't an automatic thing... the NCAA denied the Rocky Mountain bowl in Salt Lake City. Why not have yet another bowl? Why not have one in every city? If we're already over-saturated with bowls, what's one more?